A Metaphysical Journal

My name is Pawel Stroinski. I'm a philology student from Poland. I'd like to be a film director some day and a professor of Polish literature. I'm 20 years old and I listen to film scores. Enjoy!

Friday, October 14, 2005

Ethics and a story

I decided to take part in ethics course on my university. This problem has troubled me since the death of John Paul II. Aristotle counted ethics as practical philosophy as opposed to theoretical (epistemic, wisdom just for itself without any practical use) and technical.

It's hard to disagree with the philosopher of Stagira. If we travest a Latin phrase and we say that philosophy is the life teacher (magistra vitae), one of the first things to learn would be morality. It's not so easy though. If some aesthetical theory might be a sort of handbook (like Aristotle's Poetics) it's hard to say that life and making important choices is a techne (Latin ars, which is translated into English art).

Today we have more important problem, bioethics. New possibilities arose. One of major problem is euthanasia. I've recently read a great story by my friend Mariusz called simply Death. When we discussed it before it was sent to me he told me I might not like the form of the story he wrote.

Exactly the opposite. Apart from theoretically light form, a pretty exciting dramatic thriller, Death as any morality play puts a character in a moral choice. Both possibilities are presented by a character. Tom O'Donnell is not a traditional Everyman, because he already made a decision. The choice is given to him later.

This is where we come to the heart of the problem. It's hard to agree that being dumped by a girlfriend (how much he loved her) and being fired from a job warrants an euthanasia. If O'Donnell wants to take his life in such way it can be interpreted twofold. Either he is not able of commiting a suicide (and here arises the question if suicide is an act of cowardice or and act of courage) or he doesn't really want to die. Psychologist Susan Tylor interprets it in the second way and, like God (because foundation Good Death (Greek: eu-thanasia) is about playing God) gives him a second chance.

Two characters representing two different views are Jonathan Marcus, Ph. D. in psychology, and Reverend William T. Macy (having nothing in common with the great actor :D), founder of the Church of Life Renovation (CLR) In the first chapter O'Donnell watches a debate between both of them. Marcus is very calm, Macy acts like a psychopath.

Here we come to the irony of situation which makes the story so great. O'Donnell finally dies. The one who makes him commit suicide is the one who desperately wanted to save him (even going as far to use a girl pretty similar to Tom's ex-girlfriend). Reverend William T. Macy. O'Donnell doesn't take the third chance and decides to shoot himself. Although we might not agree with that decision we understand the Irishman.

Good Death was ironically the one who wanted to save Tom. But why was the foundation created? There comes the character of Malcolm Jeffrey Stewart, who explained it. He gave Marcus the money, because he... felt like it. Of course, Marcus is pretty annoyed of it. It was his life aim to bring death to those who beg for it and first, his sponsor helped him just to annoy Macy, whom he didn't like and, second, the foundation was supposed to shut down the next day. His world went into shackles...

What comes out of it? Death is a story about a big moral dilemma. I know Mariusz stays all for euthanasia. Here I can't agree with him, but not because of my religious belief. For me life is the biggest value. I couldn't forfeit it like that. I think that more than anything this is a story about letting people make their decisions. Macy's defeat is about trying too hard. And here I must agree with the author.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home